Method
How City Builders checks evidence
City Builders Association Limited (NZBN 9429053649225) publishes a page as citeable only if a reader can check every source without contacting us. Every figure carries a named source and the date it was checked. Fact and opinion are kept apart. A submission or request is described as lodged only when the page shows its date, its recipient and its reference.
What are City Builders' evidence rules?
Every factual claim must trace to a primary source a reader can open: a council report, minutes, an Act, an official dataset or an official-information response. Each figure shows the source and the date we checked it. Claims that may change, such as deadlines, budgets or statuses, carry a "checked" date. If no source can be found, the claim is not published.
In plain language:
- Primary first. We cite the council, agency or Act itself, not a news story about it, wherever the original is public.
- Every number is dated. "7.9% (Auckland Council, checked 19 October 2026)" rather than "about 8%".
- Forecasts are called forecasts. A Long-term Plan forecast, such as 3.5%, is not described as a cap, a limit or a promise.
- Fact and opinion are labelled. Analysis and argument are marked "Opinion" and carry the author's name.
- Quotes are real and sourced. A named quote appears only if we can link to where it was said or written.
- No invented precision. We do not round, extrapolate or combine official figures into new ones without showing the working.
When does City Builders say something was "lodged"?
Only when the page shows the date, the recipient and the reference. Until an agency issues a reference, we say the item was sent, with the date and recipient. The same rule covers submissions, official-information requests and complaints to the Ombudsman. "Open for evidence" means a question is still being researched. It is not a finished position.
How are official-information requests tracked?
Requests under the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act 1987 are tracked on the LGOIMA clock. The due date is 20 working days after the agency receives the request (section 13), excluding weekends, public holidays, Auckland Anniversary Day and 20 December to 10 January (section 2). An extension is recorded only when the agency has given notice under section 14, with its reasons.
What we publish from official information. We summarise and quote from released material and link to the agency's own publication where one exists. We do not republish agencies' released files in full, or full private correspondence such as ministerial emails. Personal information about officials or members of the public is removed unless it is already public and relevant.
What counts as evidence from contributors?
Contributed evidence needs a claim, a source, a date and a conflict-of-interest declaration. Accepted evidence is published with its source. Rejected evidence stays visible with the reason it was rejected. A comment thread is not a record, and a payment or membership is not verification.
How are projects and consultations compiled?
The transport tracker and consultation lists are unofficial compilations. Each row carries a source URL and the date it was fetched, and the official page governs if they differ. A row without a source URL is a draft and is not public.
What will City Builders never claim?
- "Lodged" or "formally submitted" without a date, recipient and reference.
- "Verified member" without a written verification rule.
- A petition or opt-in survey as if it had statutory force or represented all Aucklanders.
- Self-reported rates figures as a citywide dataset.
- A forecast as a cap.
How do corrections work?
If we get something wrong, we fix it in the open. Email info@citybuildersassociation.org with the page link, the error and, if possible, a source. We review every report. If a fact was wrong, we correct the page, add a dated correction note at the foot ("Corrected [date]: [what changed]"), and record significant corrections below. We never quietly change a figure. We aim to review a correction request within 5 working days.
- Corrections log: the most recent corrections, newest first, with date, page and what changed.
No corrections recorded yet.
Who runs City Builders Association?
Differences of opinion are not errors. If you disagree with an argument, you can submit evidence to the relevant question.
Is this advice?
No. Pages, tools, templates and dispatches on this site are general information and opinion about Auckland public affairs. They are not legal, financial, planning, engineering or other professional advice, and they do not replace official council information. Check the official source, and get professional advice before making decisions about your property, rates, a submission or a legal matter.
How is survey information handled? (survey privacy notice)
Privacy notice. City Builders Association Limited collects your answers, and your name and email if you give them, to record and confirm your response. Your email is used to confirm this response and, only if you tick the box, to send you the outcome. It is not added to a marketing list and is never published. Only the director can see individual responses. Results are published only as totals, never in a form that identifies you. Surveys are opt-in and are not a representative sample of Aucklanders. We keep survey emails for 24 months after the related submission, then delete them unless a dispute is open. Data is hosted with our website provider (Base44) and may be stored overseas. You can ask to see or correct your information under the Privacy Act 2020 by emailing info@citybuildersassociation.org. Full policy: Privacy.