CBA Council Project Cost Benchmark
This page tests whether an Auckland Council, Auckland Transport, Eke Panuku or Watercare project cost is reasonable by comparing its cost per kilometre (or per lane-km or m2) with published New Zealand benchmarks. Of the 23 Auckland projects we rated, 7 are far above benchmark, 1 is well above, 6 are above and 9 are within. Use the calculator to test any other project.
Calculator
$195m per km in 2025 dollars, 1.49× the benchmark: Above benchmark
Opens on the Eastern Busway, Pakūranga to Botany: official $867m budget (October 2021) over 5 km.
Advanced
- Benchmark band
- $68.0m to $131m, median $68.0m
- Band basis
- Full range of the three completed NZ busways in Te Waihanga Table 40 ($68m, $68m, $131m per km, 2025 NZD). Indicative only: three projects.
- Source
- Te Waihanga 2026, Table 40 (see busway band check)
- Escalation applied
- 3% a year, factor 1.126
- Index to use
- CGPI civil construction
- Te Waihanga stated figure (comparison only): $140m, p.47
- 1.39× $140m
The form opens on the Eastern Busway, Pakūranga to Botany, using its official $867m budget (October 2021) over the 5 km of busway AT gives for that section. It is brought to 2025 dollars at the 3% long-run rate as a rough guide only. A fixed annual rate is a shortcut; for a formal submission, take the actual quarterly CGPI values from Stats NZ Infoshare and use the index toggle. Te Waihanga figures are already in 2025 dollars: enter them with year 2025, and do not apply the 5.2% rate to reach June 2026 dollars unless you lift the band by the same amount.
- Within: up to 1.0×
- Above: over 1.0× to 1.5×
- Well above: over 1.5× to 2.0×
- Far above: over 2.0×
Auckland project ratings
CBA analysis, as at 17 November 2026
| Project | Cost per km (or lane-km) | Multiple of benchmark | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
SH1 Papakura to Drury South Stage 1NZTA state highway, Te Waihanga Table 29, p. 72Details
| $90.0m per lane-km | 6.29× | Far above benchmark |
Ō Mahurangi PenlinkDetails
| $65.4m per lane-km | 4.57× | Far above benchmark |
Mill Road Stage 1Details
| $62.5m per lane-km | 4.37× | Far above benchmark |
City Rail LinkDetails
| $1,592m per route-km | 3.23× | Far above benchmark |
Te Ara Hauāuru, Northwest Busway (Stage 2)Details
| $410m per km | 3.13× | Far above benchmark |
Lincoln Road corridor improvements, HendersonAuckland Transport local roadDetails
| $31.1m per added lane-km | 2.18× | Far above benchmark |
Ara Tūhono, Warkworth to Te HanaDetails
| $28.7m per lane-km | 2.004×right on the 2× line | Far above benchmark |
SH1 Manukau to Papakura wideningNZTA state highway, Te Waihanga Table 29, p. 72Details
| $23.9m per lane-km | 1.67× | Well above benchmark |
SH20 Mt Roskill ExtensionNZTA state highway, Te Waihanga Table 29, p. 72Details
| $20.5m per lane-km | 1.43× | Above benchmark |
SH1 Northern GatewayNZTA state highway, Te Waihanga Table 29, p. 72Details
| $19.0m per lane-km | 1.33× | Above benchmark |
Eastern Busway, Pakūranga to BotanyDetails
| $173.4m per km | 1.32× | Above benchmark |
Murphys Road upgrade, Flat BushAuckland Transport local roadDetails
| $17.4m per added lane-km | 1.21× | Above benchmark |
SH16 Lincoln to Westgate wideningNZTA state highway, Te Waihanga Table 29, p. 72Details
| $15.8m per lane-km | 1.10× | Above benchmark |
SH1 Puhoi to WarkworthDetails
| $15.3m per lane-km | 1.07× | Above benchmark |
Eastern Busway, Panmure to PakūrangaDetails
| $131m per km | 1.00× | Within benchmark |
Airport to Botany BuswayDetails
| $124m per km | 0.94× | Within benchmark |
SH20 Manukau ExtensionNZTA state highway, Te Waihanga Table 29, p. 72Details
| $11.8m per lane-km | 0.83× | Within benchmark |
Te Honohono ki Tai, Matakana Link RoadAuckland Transport with NZTA, local roadDetails
| $11.5m per lane-km | 0.81× | Within benchmark |
SH16 Upper Harbour to HobsonvilleNZTA state highway, Te Waihanga Table 29, p. 72Details
| $9.6m per lane-km | 0.67× | Within benchmark |
SH16 Upper Harbour to GreenhitheNZTA state highway, Te Waihanga Table 29, p. 72Details
| $7.6m per lane-km | 0.53× | Within benchmark |
Northern BuswayDetails
| $68m per km | 0.52× | Within benchmark |
Northern Busway extensionDetails
| $68m per km | 0.52× | Within benchmark |
SH1 Albany to SilverdaleNZTA state highway, Te Waihanga Table 29, p. 72Details
| $5.1m per lane-km | 0.36× | Within benchmark |
Several inputs are estimates or envelopes, not outturn costs. See Sources and checks for exclusions.
Nine of the added projects are NZTA state highway projects in Auckland, taken from Te Waihanga Table 29, p. 72. The three Auckland Transport local road projects are compared with the motorway band per added lane-km (or per lane-km for a new road) because it is the only road band on this page.
Multiple of the benchmark, by project
Frequently asked questions
What is the CBA Council Project Cost Benchmark?
A repeatable test for whether an Auckland Council, Auckland Transport, Eke Panuku or Watercare project cost is reasonable: normalise it to a unit cost, bring it to the benchmark year with a named index, compare it with a sourced band, and rate it.
How is a project rated?
Divide the normalised unit cost by the top of the benchmark band. Up to 1.0× is within benchmark, over 1.0× and up to 1.5× is above, over 1.5× and up to 2.0× is well above, and over 2.0× is far above. A cost under the bottom of the band is flagged to check scope and exclusions.
How are older costs brought to the benchmark year?
Use Stats NZ CGPI civil construction for roads, water and transport, and CGPI non-residential buildings for facilities. Multiply by the index at the benchmark date divided by the index at the cost date. A fixed annual rate is a shortcut only.
How does the Northwest Busway compare?
On Te Waihanga's figures, Te Ara Hauāuru, Northwest Busway (Stage 2) works out at $410m per km: 3.13× the $131m top of the completed-busway band (2.93× the Te Waihanga stated figure of $140m, comparison only). The official project area is 18 km, and the $4.1bn to $4.6bn envelope factors in 30% for escalation and administration. If that 30% is treated as a mark-up and removed, it is about $315m per km, still far above.
What are the main limits of this benchmark?
Bands rest on small samples (for example 25 NZ motorways, 4 NZ hospitals, 3 completed NZ busways), RLB building rates are Q4 2024, and no sourced public benchmark was found for libraries, pools, community centres, or water and wastewater pipes and plants. Ratings are a snapshot as at 17 November 2026, and several inputs are estimates or envelopes, not outturn costs.
How we worked this out
The method
- 1
Define the scope and the unit
Roads per lane-km, busways and rail per route-km, buildings per m2 of gross floor area. Record what is in and out of the number: land, GST, fees, contingency, escalation, financing.
- 2
Make it like-for-like with the benchmark
RLB building rates exclude GST, land, legal and professional fees, loose furniture, and site works and drainage, so strip those out. Te Waihanga road and busway figures are whole-of-project costs, so compare total project cost.
- 3
Bring it to the benchmark year
Use Stats NZ CGPI civil construction for roads, water and transport, and CGPI non-residential buildings for facilities. Benchmark year = index at benchmark date ÷ index at cost date.
- 4
Note the estimate's confidence level
A P95 or "upper" business-case figure carries more risk allowance than a P50. Record which it is before rating.
- 5
Compare with the band and rate it
Divide the normalised unit cost by the top of the band and apply the thresholds below.
- 6
Ask for the cost build-up when out of band
Use the document checklist and the LGOIMA wording on this page.
Rating thresholds
| Rating | Test (normalised unit cost vs the top of the band) | Why this line |
|---|---|---|
| Below band | Under the bottom of the band | Low numbers can mean missing scope; Oxford Global Projects found optimism bias drives overruns. |
| Within benchmark | Up to 1.0× | Inside the published P25 to P75 or low to high range. |
| Above benchmark | Over 1.0× and up to 1.5× | Published P80 risk uplifts run 15% to 68% by project type, and Te Waihanga puts cross-country conversion error at up to ±20%. A gap this size can be risk allowance or data noise, so ask questions. |
| Well above benchmark | Over 1.5× and up to 2.0× | Larger than typical risk allowances. Ask for the cost build-up and scope drivers. |
| Far above benchmark | Over 2.0× | Te Waihanga notes that even decades of escalation at about 3% a year explain unit costs about twice present-day levels, not more. |
Nine of the added rows are NZTA state highway projects in Auckland from Te Waihanga Table 29, p. 72, and are compared with the NZ motorway P75 band of $14.3m per lane-km. Three Auckland Transport local road projects (Lincoln Road corridor improvements, Murphys Road upgrade, and Te Honohono ki Tai) are also compared with that band: the two widenings use cost per added lane-km, and the new road uses cost per lane-km, because it is the only road band on this page. This is indicative only for urban arterials. SH1 Albany to Silverdale is one of the 25 projects that make up the motorway band itself. The other added new-road rows from Table 29 carry the same caveat.
NZ benchmark bands
Roads
| Benchmark | Unit | Low | Median | High | Base year | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Motorway / expressway, NZ completed (pre-2022) | NZ$m per lane-km | $7.6m | $8.6m | $14.3m | 2025 | Te Waihanga 2026, Table 28 |
| Motorway, NZTA indicative target, Upper North Island | NZ$m per lane-km | $14.0m | $17.0m | 2025 | Te Waihanga 2026, p.34 | |
| Motorway / expressway, OECD countries | NZ$m per lane-km | $3.0m | $5.5m | $8.8m | 2025 | Te Waihanga 2026, Table 28 |
Rapid transit
| Benchmark | Unit | Low | Median | High | Base year | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Busway, NZ completed projects | NZ$m per km | $68.0m | $68.0m | $131m | 2025 | Te Waihanga 2026, Table 40 (see busway band check) |
| Light rail, at-grade (75%+ at grade), OECD | NZ$m per km | $64.0m | $82.0m | $102m | 2025 | Te Waihanga 2026, Table 39 |
| Light rail, partly tunnelled or elevated, OECD | NZ$m per km | $123m | $175m | $251m | 2025 | Te Waihanga 2026, Table 39 |
| Light rail, tunnelled or elevated, OECD | NZ$m per km | $221m | $274m | $506m | 2025 | Te Waihanga 2026, Table 39 |
| Heavy rail, tunnelled or elevated, OECD | NZ$m per km | $230m | $308m | $493m | 2025 | Te Waihanga 2026, Table 39 |
Busway band check
| Test on Te Waihanga Table 40 | Result (2025 NZ$m per km) |
|---|---|
| Completed busways listed | $68m, $68m, $131m (three projects) |
| Median of the three | $68m |
| 75th percentile of the three (linear interpolation) | $99.5m |
| Highest completed | $131m |
| Te Waihanga stated figure (comparison only): 'P75 of completed busways' (p.47) | $140m: not reproducible from Table 40 |
| 75th percentile if the $171m Pakūranga to Botany estimate is added | $141m |
The $140m figure does not stand as a percentile of completed busways. It lines up with a set that includes the Pakūranga to Botany estimate, which is not a completed cost; that is an inference, and Te Waihanga does not say so. This page now uses $68m to $131m, the full range of completed projects, as the busway band, and shows $140m only as a Te Waihanga stated figure, for comparison. The highest completed cost is used rather than $99.5m because a percentile of three projects is not meaningful. With only three projects, treat any busway rating as indicative.
Buildings (Auckland unless stated)
| Benchmark | Unit | Low | Median | High | Base year | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hospital, new build (NAMP unit costs) | NZ$ per m2 GFA | $12,107 | $16,042 | 2023 | Te Waihanga 2026 (citing NZIER 2023) | |
| Office, investment grade, outside CBD, up to 10 storeys | NZ$ per m2 GFA | $4,500 | $5,000 | 2024 | RLB Riders Digest NZ 2025 | |
| Office, walk-up, outside CBD | NZ$ per m2 GFA | $4,250 | $4,750 | 2024 | RLB Riders Digest NZ 2025 | |
| Office, investment grade, CBD, up to 10 storeys | NZ$ per m2 GFA | $5,000 | $5,500 | 2024 | RLB Riders Digest NZ 2025 | |
| Office, prestige, CBD, 10 to 25 storeys | NZ$ per m2 GFA | $5,500 | $6,500 | 2024 | RLB Riders Digest NZ 2025 | |
| Car park, open-deck multi-storey | NZ$ per m2 GFA | $1,700 | $2,300 | 2024 | RLB Riders Digest NZ 2025 | |
| Car park, basement, outside CBD | NZ$ per m2 GFA | $3,500 | $4,500 | 2024 | RLB Riders Digest NZ 2025 | |
| Industrial / depot shed, metal clad, 6 m, 4,500 m2 | NZ$ per m2 GFA | $1,200 | $1,400 | 2024 | RLB Riders Digest NZ 2025 | |
| Aged care, single-storey facility | NZ$ per m2 GFA | $4,500 | $5,500 | 2024 | RLB Riders Digest NZ 2025 | |
| Apartments, up to 10 storeys with lift | NZ$ per m2 GFA | $5,500 | $6,000 | 2024 | RLB Riders Digest NZ 2025 | |
| Townhouses, 90 to 120 m2 per unit | NZ$ per m2 GFA | $2,950 | $3,450 | 2024 | RLB Riders Digest NZ 2025 | |
| Supermarket / variety store | NZ$ per m2 GFA | $3,000 | $3,600 | 2024 | RLB Riders Digest NZ 2025 |
RLB rates are tender-level building costs as at Q4 2024 and exclude GST, land, legal and professional fees, loose furniture and fittings, and site works and drainage. RLB publishes no rate for libraries, pools or community centres. Te Waihanga reports NZ hospital upgrade costs at around 20% above international benchmarks per m2.
Contingency and escalation
Reference-class risk uplift (international)
| Project type | Mean overrun | P50 uplift | P80 uplift |
|---|---|---|---|
| Roads | 22% | 16% | 47% |
| Tunnels | 36% | 24% | 68% |
| Rail stations | 43% | 18% | 60% |
| Transmission lines | 8% | 0% | 15% |
| Wind power | 12% | 1% | 22% |
| Hospitals | 23% | 0% | 23% |
Source: Oxford Global Projects, reference class forecasting.
Escalation signals, 2026
| Measure | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| CGPI civil construction, year to June 2026 | 5.2% | Stats NZ via NZIER/RLB |
| CGPI civil construction, June 2026 quarter | 2.7% | Stats NZ via NZIER/RLB |
| CGPI non-residential, year to June 2026 | 2.2% | Stats NZ via NBR |
| CGPI residential, year to June 2026 | 2.8% | Stats NZ via NBR |
| NZIER forecast civil, Dec 2026 quarter | 6.0% | NZIER/RLB Aug 2026 |
| NZIER forecast civil, low point H2 2027 | 1.8% | NZIER/RLB Aug 2026 |
| QV non-residential excl. education, annual | 2.0% | QV, Sept 2026 |
| JLL Asia Pacific tender prices, 2027 | 3.8% to 4.7% | JLL, Oct 2026 |
Use the uplift table to judge whether a project's contingency is in a normal range, not as a target. NZIER warns that CGPI civil is a national average across all types of work, so treat it with care for any single project.
What JLL's index covers
| Building type (global average) | US$ per m2 |
|---|---|
| Office, shell and core | 2,600 to 3,410 |
| High-rise residential | 2,280 to 3,710 |
| Industrial and logistics | 980 to 1,520 |
- Based on JLL's Construction Costs Index, Cost Monitor and Projects database: 1,000+ projects, six building types, 14 markets.
- Annual escalation of 3% to 6% is the new planning baseline, against 2% to 3% before 2020; costs rose 25% to 30% on average over five years, and up to 40% in some markets.
- Tender prices outran consumer prices most in Germany, Australia and Singapore; they were broadly in line in the UK, Spain, Canada, France and China.
- Skilled labour shortages are reported by 64% of JLL's markets; electricians and carpenters (64%) and plumbers and HVAC technicians (58%) are named as cost drivers.
- New Zealand and Auckland are not named in the public summary. The full report, including the list of 14 markets, sits behind a download form.
Use JLL for direction, meaning escalation and labour pressure, not as a local yardstick. Its building rates are global US dollar averages for commercial property, not council infrastructure.
Australian proxies
| City (RLB, Q4 2024) | Currency | Office, Grade A, per m2 | Warehouse, per m2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Auckland | NZD | 5,000 to 6,600 | 1,200 to 1,500 |
| Sydney | AUD | 3,950 to 5,900 | 1,060 to 1,760 |
| Melbourne | AUD | 3,700 to 5,200 | 1,100 to 1,660 |
| Brisbane | AUD | 3,900 to 5,400 | 1,260 to 1,860 |
These figures come from RLB's international table, in local currency and not exchange-rate adjusted, so they are proxies only. On roads, Te Waihanga found NZ urban motorway unit costs similar to Australia's on median and middle-50% range, and NZ construction wages around 35% below Australia's.
If a project is out of band
Documents to request
- The cost estimate behind the published figure, with its date, price basis and confidence level (P50, P90 or P95).
- The elemental or trade cost plan from the quantity surveyor, including base cost, contingency and escalation shown separately.
- Scope quantities: GFA, lane-km or route-km, number of stations or structures, and share of length on bridges or in tunnels.
- Land and property, consenting, professional fees, client-side management and financing costs, each shown separately.
- Any independent cost review, peer review or Te Waihanga / Treasury gateway assessment.
- Comparable projects or benchmarks the organisation used to test the estimate.
- Procurement approach, number of tenderers, and tender results against the pre-tender estimate.
- The latest business case with its benefit-cost ratio and the cost figure used in it.
LGOIMA request wording
Subject: LGOIMA request: cost basis for {project name}
Under the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act 1987, please provide the following for {project name}:
1. The current total cost estimate, the date it was prepared, the price base year, and whether it is a P50, P90, P95 or other confidence-level estimate.
2. A breakdown of that estimate into base construction cost, contingency, escalation, land and property, consenting, professional and design fees, client-side management, and financing.
3. The scope quantities the estimate is based on (for example gross floor area in m2, lane-kilometres, route-kilometres, number of stations or structures).
4. Any cost plan or estimate prepared by a quantity surveyor or cost consultant, and any independent cost review or peer review.
5. Any benchmarking of the project's unit cost against other New Zealand or international projects carried out by or for the organisation.
6. For any part of the project already tendered, the pre-tender estimate and the accepted tender price.
If any part of this request is refused or would take substantial collation, please release the remaining parts and tell us which parts are affected. We are happy to receive documents electronically.
City Builders AssociationAuckland Council requests go to officialinformation@aucklandcouncil.govt.nz. Send requests about Auckland Transport, Eke Panuku or Watercare projects to that organisation's own official information contact. You can follow CBA's own requests on the LGOIMA tracker.
Sources and checks
Te Waihanga 2025-dollar unit costs unless stated. No rating changes when the busway band top is $131m rather than the Te Waihanga stated figure of $140m. East West Link was excluded: Te Waihanga left it out of its own motorway distribution because of unusual scope, and its lane-km figure comes from diagrams, so the arithmetic multiple is not a reliable finding. We also reviewed the Central Interceptor and the Northcote Community Hub, which are left unrated because no sourced public band exists for wastewater tunnels or community centres. These ratings are a snapshot as at 17 November 2026; several inputs are estimates or envelopes, not outturn costs.
Eastern Busway check
| Official figure | What it covers | Date | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| $867m | Confirmed budget for the Pakūranga to Botany section. Includes cycling and walking paths, roading improvements and the Reeves Road flyover. | October 2021 | https://ourauckland.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz/news/2021/10/eastern-busway-gets-green-light/ |
| $804m | AT's 'current project total' after approving Stages 3c and 4i, which added $198m (Burswood busway, 107 m bridge, Burswood stop, Botany station upgrade). AT does not say whether it covers the whole section; the Botany link through Guys Reserve was unfunded at the time. | 28 September 2023 | https://at.govt.nz/about-us/news-events/media-centre/2023-media-releases/approval-of-next-phase-of-eastern-busway-project |
| $101m | NZTA and Auckland Council funding for the Botany link through Guys Reserve. This is an addition, not a project total. | February 2026 | https://at.govt.nz/projects-and-initiatives/eastern-busway |
- Comparable figure
- $867m. It is the only official figure published as the cost of the Pakūranga to Botany section. It is a 2021 budget in 2021 dollars and predates later scope changes.
- Length
- 5 km of busway for Pakūranga to Botany, with 5 stations and 12 km of walking and cycleways (AT project page, updated 26 October 2026). The whole Panmure to Botany busway is 7 km (OurAuckland, October 2021).
- Unit cost
- $867m ÷ 5 km = $173.4m per km in 2021 dollars, before escalation: 1.32× the $131m band top (1.24× the Te Waihanga stated figure of $140m, comparison only). Above benchmark; escalating to 2025 dollars would raise it. Te Waihanga's own $171m per km gives 1.31×.
- Current official total
- Not found. $804m plus $101m is $905m, but that is a sum of two figures, not a published total, so it is not used.
- Te Waihanga's $856m
- A figure used by Te Waihanga that we could not find in any AT or council document. It is lower than the 2021 budget of $867m even though it is stated in 2025 dollars, and Te Waihanga does not explain the gap.
Gaps and limits
- JLL's 14-market list and city rates are in the gated full report; NZ coverage could not be confirmed.
- No public 2026 NZ Riders Digest was found; building rates are Q4 2024 and need escalating.
- QV CostBuilder and Rawlinsons $/m2 rates are subscription-only and not used here.
- No sourced public benchmark was found for libraries, pools, community centres, or water and wastewater pipes and plants; Watercare projects need a separate source.
- No published Auckland Council or AT standard unit-cost schedule was found.
- Bands rest on small samples (for example 25 NZ motorways, 4 NZ hospitals, 3 completed NZ busways) and do not adjust for ground conditions, structures or urban constraints.
- Proposed roads are rated against the completed-motorway band; the NZTA $17m target is shown as a sensitivity. Te Waihanga's distribution for proposed RoNS (P75 $98.9m per lane-km) is not used as a benchmark because it describes estimates, not delivered costs.
- Escalation from CGPI is a national average; NZIER cautions against applying it to a single project without care.
Sources
- Global Construction Costs Index 2026. JLL, 15 Oct 2026.
- Higher construction costs reshape real estate viability, JLL reports. JLL newsroom, 15 Oct 2026.
- Understanding capacity upgrade pressures across infrastructure networks. Te Waihanga, 2026.
- Making every dollar count. Te Waihanga, Sept 2026.
- The lay of the land: Benchmarking NZ's infrastructure delivery costs. Te Waihanga, Dec 2022.
- NZIC benchmark report (cost, schedule and overrun reference classes). Oxford Global Projects for Te Waihanga, 2022.
- Riders Digest 2025, New Zealand. Rider Levett Bucknall, Feb 2025.
- NZIER Forecast Infrastructure Report, construction costs. RLB / NZIER, Aug 2026.
- Civil construction inflation to hit 6%, on oil price shocks. NBR, 4 Sept 2026.
- Price indexes for the construction industry. Stats NZ.
- Diesel rebound drives construction costs upward. QV, 1 Sept 2026.
- Eastern Busway gets green light ($867m budget). OurAuckland, Oct 2021.
- Approval of next phase of Eastern Busway project ($804m). Auckland Transport, 28 Sept 2023.
- Eastern Busway project page ($101m, 5 km). Auckland Transport, Updated 26 Oct 2026.
- Te Ara Hauāuru, Northwest Busway Investment Case Summary. NZTA via beehive.govt.nz, April 2025.
- Mill Road Stage 1 Investment Case Summary. NZTA via beehive.govt.nz, April 2025.
- Regulatory Impact Statement: Tolling Penlink ($830m as at June 2022). Ministry of Transport, 14 Oct 2022.
- Delayed again: Penlink opening set for late 2029. Local Matters, 26 Mar 2026.
- Financial update: City Rail Link ($5.493bn). OurAuckland, 15 Mar 2023.
- City Rail Link project overview (3.45 km tunnels). City Rail Link Ltd.
- Warkworth to Te Hana. NZ Infrastructure Pipeline.