How Auckland's big projects compare with New Zealand cost benchmarks
Four Auckland transport projects cost more than three times the top of their benchmark band per km, and four busways sit within. The questions agencies should answer.

We compared the published costs of nine Auckland transport projects with sourced New Zealand and international unit-cost benchmarks, using the CBA Council Project Cost Benchmark. Four of them, Ō Mahurangi Penlink, Mill Road Stage 1, City Rail Link and the Northwest Busway (Stage 2), cost more than three times the top of their benchmark band per kilometre, and Ara Tūhono sits right on the 2x line. Four busways sit within their band. A high multiple is not proof of waste: it is a question the responsible agency should be able to answer, and we set those questions out below.
How the test works
The benchmark divides a project's cost by its length (lane-km for roads, route-km for busways and rail) and compares the result with the top of a published band. A project up to 1.0x the band top is within benchmark, over 1.0x to 1.5x is above, over 1.5x to 2.0x is well above, and over 2.0x is far above. The full method, bands and calculator are on the benchmark page.
Three bands are used here, all from Te Waihanga's report Understanding capacity upgrade pressures across infrastructure networks (2026):
- Roads: $14.3m per lane-km, the 75th percentile of 25 completed New Zealand motorway and expressway projects (Table 28, p. 70).
- Busways: $131m per km, the highest of the three completed New Zealand busways (Table 40, p. 85).
- Tunnelled heavy rail: $493m per km, the 75th percentile of 49 OECD projects (Table 39, p. 85).
Unit costs are Te Waihanga's 2025-dollar figures unless stated. Most inputs are estimates or funding envelopes, not final costs.
The results
| Project | Cost per km | Multiple | Rating | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Ō Mahurangi Penlink | $65.4m per lane-km | 4.57x | Far above | | Mill Road Stage 1 | $62.5m per lane-km | 4.37x | Far above | | City Rail Link | $1,592m per route-km | 3.23x | Far above | | Te Ara Hauāuru, Northwest Busway (Stage 2) | $410m per km | 3.13x | Far above | | Ara Tūhono, Warkworth to Te Hana | $28.7m per lane-km | 2.004x | Far above, on the 2x line | | Eastern Busway, Panmure to Pakūranga | $131m per km | 1.00x | Within | | Airport to Botany Busway | $124m per km | 0.94x | Within | | Northern Busway | $68m per km | 0.52x | Within | | Northern Busway extension | $68m per km | 0.52x | Within |
Sources for each row are given in the project notes below.
Project notes
Ō Mahurangi Penlink (NZTA), 4.57x. Te Waihanga puts the cost at $915m in 2025 dollars over 14 lane-km (Table 29, p. 72). NZTA's own estimate is $830m as at June 2022 (Ministry of Transport, Regulatory Impact Statement: Tolling Penlink, finalised 14 October 2022, p. 4). These are the same estimate on different price bases. On 25 March 2026 NZTA said opening had moved to late 2029 and that "the original cost estimate of $830 million is expected to increase due to programme delays" (NZTA media release, 25 March 2026). The road includes the Wēiti River Bridge, so a motorway band is not a perfect comparison.
Mill Road Stage 1 (NZTA), 4.37x. The investment envelope is $1.75bn to $2.05bn "to design, consent, acquire land and construct the project" (NZTA, Mill Road Stage 1 Investment Case Summary, April 2025, p. 2). Land, design and consenting are inside that figure. The rating uses the lower end over 28 lane-km (Te Waihanga, Table 30, p. 73).
City Rail Link (City Rail Link Ltd), 3.23x. $5.493bn is the revised total City Rail Link Ltd requested from its sponsors on 15 March 2023, not a figure approved at that date (OurAuckland, 15 March 2023). It covers twin 3.45 km tunnels plus two new underground stations, a redeveloped Maungawhau station and the conversion of Waitematā to a through station (City Rail Link Ltd, project overview). It is not restated in 2025 dollars, and a per-km comparison is harsh on a project with this much station work. Passenger services began on 13 September 2026 (Auckland Transport, 13 September 2026).
Te Ara Hauāuru, Northwest Busway, Stage 2 (NZTA), 3.13x. The Stage 2 envelope is $4,100m to $4,600m, and NZTA's footnote says the envelopes "factor in 30% for escalation and administration" (NZTA, Northwest Busway Investment Case Summary, April 2025, p. 2). The $410m per km is Te Waihanga's figure using its own length measure (Table 40, p. 85); Te Waihanga does not say which section that length covers, and the official project area is 18 km along SH16 (NZTA, April 2025, p. 2). If the 30% allowance is treated as a mark-up and removed, the multiple is about 2.41x, still far above; the summary does not say how the 30% is applied. These figures are as at April 2025.
Ara Tūhono, Warkworth to Te Hana (NZTA), 2.004x. Te Waihanga's lower 2023 estimate, in 2025 dollars, is $2,981m over 104 lane-km, or $28.7m per lane-km (Table 30, p. 73). That is 2.004 times the band top: technically over the 2x line, but only by 0.2%, so it should be read as on the boundary between well above and far above. Against NZTA's own $17m Upper North Island target (Te Waihanga, p. 34) it is 1.69x. Main construction starts in November 2027 and the road is expected to open in 2033 (Government release, 30 July 2026, reproduced by National Infrastructure Funding and Financing, 10 August 2026).
The four busways within band. Panmure to Pakūranga ($340m over 2.6 km), Airport to Botany ($2,227m over 18.0 km, a 2021 estimate), the Northern Busway ($504m over 7.45 km) and its extension ($341m over 5.0 km) all sit at or under $131m per km (Te Waihanga, Table 40, p. 85). The band rests on only three completed projects, so busway ratings are indicative.
Not rated. We found no sourced public benchmark for wastewater tunnels, pools, libraries or community centres, so the Central Interceptor and the Northcote Community Hub are marked "no benchmark". The benchmark page also lists SH1 Puhoi to Warkworth and the Eastern Busway, Pakūranga to Botany section; we have left both out of this article because a settled official cost for each is still to be confirmed.
Questions agencies should answer
- NZTA, Northwest Busway Stage 2: what makes up the $4.1bn to $4.6bn envelope, how the 30% allowance is applied, what is included for property and the Newton connection, and how many route-km the envelope covers?
- NZTA, Penlink: what is the current total estimate after the March 2026 delay, on what price base, and what share relates to the Wēiti River Bridge?
- NZTA, Mill Road Stage 1: how does the envelope split between land, design and consenting, construction, contingency and escalation, at what confidence level, and how many lane-km are added?
- NZTA, Ara Tūhono: what is the nominal design-and-build capital cost and its price base, and what lane-km and tunnel length does it assume?
- City Rail Link sponsors: what is the final cost, split between tunnels, stations and systems?
Requests to Auckland Council go under the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act 1987; requests to NZTA and Crown entities go under the Official Information Act 1982. You can follow CBA's requests on the LGOIMA tracker.
Related
- CBA Council Project Cost Benchmark
- LGOIMA tracker
- The Real Cost of Widening a Road: Why Multimodal Projects Cost Vastly More
- What should be Auckland's top 10 priority transport infrastructure projects?
- Investigations
Sources
- Te Waihanga, Understanding capacity upgrade pressures across infrastructure networks (2026), Tables 28 to 30 (pp. 70 to 73), Tables 39 and 40 (p. 85), p. 34: https://media.umbraco.io/te-waihanga-30-year-strategy/015n3u1n/understanding-capacity-upgrade-pressures-across-infrastructure-networks-final.pdf
- Ministry of Transport, Regulatory Impact Statement: Tolling Penlink (finalised 14 October 2022), p. 4: https://www.regulation.govt.nz/assets/RIS-Documents/ria-transport-tolpen-oct22.pdf
- NZTA media release, New North Auckland highway: Penlink to open in 2029 (25 March 2026), as republished by Scoop: https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/AK2603/S00559/new-north-auckland-highway-penlinkto-open-in-2029.htm
- NZTA, Mill Road Stage 1 Investment Case Summary (April 2025), p. 2: https://www.beehive.govt.nz/sites/default/files/2025-04/Mill%20Road%20Investment%20Case%20Summary.pdf
- OurAuckland, Financial update: City Rail Link and storm impacts (15 March 2023): https://ourauckland.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz/news/2023/03/financial-update-city-rail-link-and-storm-impacts/
- City Rail Link Ltd, project overview: https://www.cityraillink.co.nz/city-rail-link-project-overview
- Auckland Transport, New era of transport in Auckland begins (13 September 2026): https://at.govt.nz/about-us/news-events/media-centre/2026-media-releases/new-era-of-transport-in-auckland-begins
- NZTA, Te Ara Hauāuru, Northwest Busway Investment Case Summary (April 2025), p. 2: https://www.beehive.govt.nz/sites/default/files/2025-04/Northwest%20Busway%20Investment%20Case%20Summary.pdf
- National Infrastructure Funding and Financing, Warkworth to Te Hana PPP signed (10 August 2026, reproducing the 30 July 2026 Government release): https://nationalinfrastructure.govt.nz/2026/08/warkworth-to-te-hana-ppp-signed/
Frequently asked questions
Does "far above benchmark" mean money has been wasted?
No. It means the cost per km is more than twice the top of a published band. Scope, ground conditions, land, stations, risk allowances and price basis can all explain a gap. The rating shows where an agency should explain its numbers.
Why is Ara Tūhono described as on the line?
Its unit cost is 2.004 times the band top. The far above rating starts at more than 2.0x, so it qualifies by a 0.2% margin. Against NZTA's own $17m target it would be 1.69x.
Why are some busways within benchmark when the Northwest Busway is far above?
The busway band is set by the three completed New Zealand busways. Panmure to Pakūranga sets the top at $131m per km; the Northwest Busway Stage 2 envelope works out at $410m per km on Te Waihanga's figures.
Why are pools, libraries and community centres not rated?
No sourced public unit-cost benchmark was found for them, or for wastewater tunnels, so we mark them "no benchmark" rather than compare them with an unsuitable band.
Can I test another project?
Yes. The calculator on the CBA Council Project Cost Benchmark (https://thecitybuilder.com/cost-benchmark) page takes a cost, a length or floor area and a year, and returns a multiple and rating.
Join the discussion
Community members are invited to add perspective, evidence, or a sharp question. Be specific and keep it civil.
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Written by Mark Pervan, Director, City Builders Association Limited
Mark Pervan is the founder and director of City Builders Association Limited, an Auckland civic think tank funded by membership and voluntary contributions. He has run manufacturing plants, with global sourcing and supply chain management in the same role, and has been project manager on multiple commercial and residential building projects. He was also responsible for product design and development across multiple mediums, and served as sales and marketing manager. He is a company director and business owner, including as a director of Idea Foundry. He served three years as an elected member of the Puketāpapa Local Board (2022–2025) and was a council candidate for the Albert-Eden-Puketāpapa ward of Auckland Council.
Mark on LinkedIn
